UPDATE: Proposal to merge black schools draws fire
by Shelia Byrd/The Associated Press
9 months ago | 1241 views | 14 14 comments | 6 6 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Mississippi Gov. Haley Barbour holds a copy of his Fiscal Year 2011 budget during a news conference at the Sillers Building in Jackson on Monday. Barbour is calling for a sweeping reorganization of state government, including proposals to merge eight universities into five and reduce the number of school districts by a third. (AP Photo/The Clarion-Ledger, Greg Jenson)
Mississippi Gov. Haley Barbour holds a copy of his Fiscal Year 2011 budget during a news conference at the Sillers Building in Jackson on Monday. Barbour is calling for a sweeping reorganization of state government, including proposals to merge eight universities into five and reduce the number of school districts by a third. (AP Photo/The Clarion-Ledger, Greg Jenson)
slideshow
JACKSON — Gov. Haley Barbour's plan to merge Mississippi's three historically black universities has created a tense atmosphere in a state saddled with a violent civil rights past and a decades-long legal battle over the historic underfunding of those schools.

At Jackson State University, students have turned to Twitter and Facebook to gather signatures on a petition to block the move proposed by the Republican governor. A half-dozen students attended a state College Board meeting Thursday expecting some discussion about the proposal, but there was none.

"I personally believe they undermined the uniqueness of the black colleges and how far we've come with the little resources we have," said Marissa Simms, a 20-year-old JSU student.

Many of the nation's public historically black colleges and universities, known as HBCUs, were founded more than a century ago. Mississippi's own Alcorn State University in Lorman was the country's first land-grant black college.

The state's other historically black campus is Mississippi Valley State University in Itta Bena.

Nationwide, there are 42 public HBCUs and dozens more private institutions. White House officials and representatives of national organizations say the colleges play a vital role in an initiative by the Democratic Obama administration.

Under Barbour's plan, no campuses would close but Alcorn State and Valley would be merged into Jackson State. Each of the smaller schools is roughly 100 miles from Jackson. Barbour said the merger would save money by reducing administrative costs and eliminating academic duplication.

He also wants to consolidate Mississippi University for Women with nearby Mississippi State University.

The governor said the restructuring could save the state $35 million out of a nearly $5.5 billion budget for the fiscal year that begins July 1.

The black university presidents have made clear they want to remain independent.

"The governor's proposed budget cuts will change the face of higher education in Mississippi for decades," JSU President Ronald Mason said in a statement.

Alcorn State President George Ross said the university leaders didn't find out about the plan until Monday.

"We don't have a lot of detail. We're reacting to something without much of the knowledge to react to it," Ross said.

Some key lawmakers said they wouldn't support the plan when the Legislature convenes in January.

"I don't think the House is going to give it much consideration," said Rep. Cecil Brown, a white Democrat from Jackson.

Rep. Adrienne Wooten, a black Democrat from Jackson, said all universities should be treated the same.

"I only know there are certain universities that are having to come forward and prove why they should remain open. That's not right," she said.

Barbour said a state with about 2.9 million residents can't afford eight universities. He said Monday he's not worried about appearing racially insensitive with his proposal.

John S. Wilson, executive director of the White House Initiative on Historically Black Colleges and Universities, questions Barbour's rationale. Wilson said improving the campuses' capacity to educate more students, not cost-savings, should be the goal.

Wilson said the president wants the U.S. to have the highest proportion of college graduates in the world by 2020.

"In order to reach the 2020 goal, we're going to need greatness from the HBCUs," Wilson said. "Would this result in a great move in higher education for African-Americans in the state of Mississippi? Would it result in a great institution? I think that's unclear."

Black universities disproportionately enroll low-income students and minorities, demographic groups that rank much lower than their white counterparts in receiving college degrees.

Napoleon Moses, a vice president of the National Association for Equal Opportunity in Higher Education in Washington, D.C., said Mississippi should follow Louisiana's lead. He said Louisiana higher education officials are examining all the state's universities and colleges, not just its three HBCUs.

Moses called Barbour's proposal an "insensitive recommendation devoid of critical data." He also said the state has the "ugliest history of perpetuating a dual and unequal higher education system."

In 1975, Jake Ayers Sr. filed a lawsuit accusing Mississippi of giving more financial support to predominantly white schools. The state settled the lawsuit in 2002 and agreed to direct $503 million to the three historically black schools, collectively, over 17 years.

Negotiations for the lawsuit settlement included discussions of merging Mississippi Valley State University with nearby Delta State University, a predominantly white school. Nothing came of those merger talks.

Bobby Harrison from the NEMS Daily Journal is covering today's College Board meeting. Watch for more in Friday's NEMS Daily Journal newspaper.
comments (14)
« spanky_1964 wrote on Friday, Nov 20 at 07:56 AM »
I am not seeing a large number of folks that are against merging the W with MSU.. I think these folks who wait on Financial Aid and then leave should be made to pay it back. If you dont finish the class the you dont get the aid. Where are all the historically white schools? If the state has them schools then we are racist. Lets quit tabbing these schools as historically black and say they are just colleges just like anything else. Now who is holding on to the past here? I thought we were trying to move past what happened 40 or more years ago and get over it. Calling these schools is a recial slur in my opinion. Lets get past it and move on for the great state of Mississippi.
report abuse
« americasgone wrote on Friday, Nov 20 at 06:49 AM »
If a bunch of college kids are against it it is probably a good idea
report abuse
« shuffle02 wrote on Thursday, Nov 19 at 10:00 PM »
-----"I personally believe they undermined the uniqueness of the black colleges and how far we've come with the little resources we have," said Marissa Simms, a 20-year-old JSU student.-----

Well, Marissa, you should be proud of Barbour for wanting to help JSU, Alcorn and Valley have more resources by pooling them together.

I really think the thing to remember with all of this, including school district consolidation, is that the results will not be immediate. The results(financial efficacy) will have a snowball effect. It will take a couple of years for personnel and properties to be merged into a more efficient unit with the universities and school districts. The good thing is that these effects will actually be long term, and I believe, these decisions could hold more historical impact than most of the other decisions he's made in his time as Governor. The legislature would be wise to take a long look at implementing some of these recommendations.
report abuse
« 2Cool4School wrote on Thursday, Nov 19 at 08:32 PM »
My question is, would merging the colleges save any money anyway? No one has taken into account the devistating economic impact closing these schools would have on local economies. Barbor is just like Bush, running through life half cocked. The studies have shown that internet media is the best way to educate. Virtual academies are popping up everywhere and out performing public schools by a great deal. The environmental impact, as well as, economic savings would serve Ms much better. Mr. Barbour the future is in computers and internet media. Finally, please, Mr. Barbour, stop being such a racist. It is evident to whole world that you don't like minorities of any kind. The sad thing is you represent what the world perceives as Ms.
report abuse
« jteasler wrote on Thursday, Nov 19 at 08:08 PM »
I do not see the big deal of merging 3 historically black colleges into one historically black college. It is not really even merging if you do not close the campuses. It is just centralizing the overhead. It will be best for all students that go there. It would open up more classes to be offered to students on-line. What if the universities just kept their names just had one single administrator class such as payroll accounting president and all the rest would everybody be happy?
report abuse
« ultracreep wrote on Thursday, Nov 19 at 07:17 PM »
I am all for people having as many opportunities for education as possible, but I have to agree with wool on one thing: many here go to school to get the financial aid check, period. When I started school this semester the parking lot was packed...you couldn't find a space anywhere. The day after the last financial aid check came, half the parking lot and half the classes were empty.
report abuse
« sandlot1959 wrote on Thursday, Nov 19 at 06:41 PM »
Barbour 'put us in a hole' is silly...he's been cutting the budget with the legislature pushing back all the way...if anything he has saved us from cataclysm...If Kirk Fordice, with ALL of his faults, hadn't started the rainy day fund, and if Haley hadn't filled it back up during his first term, Mississippi would be in much worse condition than today...thats not politics, just a fact...
report abuse
« dawgbone wrote on Thursday, Nov 19 at 06:28 PM »
Wool, don't forget LUCK
report abuse
« Woolhat wrote on Thursday, Nov 19 at 06:22 PM »
The "Thought for Today" in a DJ this week was Lillian Smith's observation: "Education is a private matter between the person and the world of knowledge and experience, and has little to do with school or college."

This flap proves Ms Smith's point. It isn't about education. It's about political power, turf protecting, etc. If Mississippi's colleges had been run like a business, all of them would have been put under a single administrator years ago, and program duplication ended. Won't happen.

The colleges are ego trips for influential alumni, political patronage for the parties, middle-class welfare for those who have advanced degrees but no discernible skills, etc. We will keep fostering the fiction that they're going to lead us out of the Wilderness...yada yada yada, while in fact, the overwhelming majority of our college kids should be picking up sweet potatoes, cutting pulpwood, or picking up trash on the highway.

Putting a cow pie in the oven doesn't make it cake. Putting ill-prepared, functionally illiterate kids in a "university," and keeping them there until the student aid checks quit coming doesn't make them "educated." It just creates a sense of entitlement -- a feeling that "I deserve better, 'cause I'm ejikated."

Cream always rises. The able get educated. They just don't always get degrees. Those of us who hire America's work force know the truth. A college diploma doesn't mean beans any more.

report abuse
« dawgbone wrote on Thursday, Nov 19 at 06:19 PM »
Barbour put us into a hole?????????????
report abuse
« dawgbone wrote on Thursday, Nov 19 at 06:17 PM »
report abuse
« SEANKAUFMAN wrote on Thursday, Nov 19 at 06:07 PM »
Haley keeps on making Mississippi proud doesn't he?
report abuse
« 5960lady wrote on Thursday, Nov 19 at 03:39 PM »
Let you voices be heard, you own your state barbour works for the people of ms.

Barbour put ms. into a hole now he is trying to scrum out of the mess hes got us in.

If we have to take to the streets then thats what we will do.
report abuse
« sampson04 wrote on Thursday, Nov 19 at 03:11 PM »
He planned to merge several schools not just the black colleges....get over it!
report abuse