Facebook Twitter eEdition Your News Business Directory List Business Classifieds Subscribe NEMisJobs NEMissPreps NEMSHomes NEMSDeals

Childers sticks with Dems, but pundits wonder
by patsy.brumfield@djournal.com
 From the front row
2 years ago | 1493 views | 9 9 comments | 10 10 recommendations | email to a friend | print | permalink

Gee, no surprise that I've been wrong before.

I once wrote speeches for Lt. Amy Tuck that said something to the effect: I know people say I should switch to the GOP, but darn it, I'm a Democrat and Hell will freeze over before I ever do anything different.

Feeling colder out there?

Anyway, U.S. Rep. Travis Childers insists he's a Democrat with a Big D, and I believe him. But there's no doubt it's hard to be a conservative D, although he's found a real home with like-minded colleagues as a Blue Dog.

Tuesday, in the Daily Journal Editorial Board, he said very strongly his party loyalty is not up for grabs, as apparently it's been lately with a fellow Blue Dog or so. He appears not to be running scared about what his North Mississippi constituents think about his voting record, which is hardly liberal.

And so, it's got to be hard on him when outsiders speculate very publicly that he'll be among the next to change parties. Personally, he's sorry to see friend Rep. Parker Griffith of Alabama make the move.

Check out this Christian Science Monitor comment, which doesn't look like anybody spoke with the man himself:

Emory University prof. speculates Childers next Dem. defector

“This has to be a calculation that it’s going to be easier for a congressman to have a career as a Republican than a Democrat, even if it means joining the minority party, [and] that really is quite astonishing,” says Merle Black, a political science professor at Emory University in Atlanta and author of “Divided America: The Ferocious Power Struggle in American Politics.” “The result is you might see more changes or challenges within the Deep South from some of these districts where Democrats think it’s easier to win election as a Republican.”

Freshman Rep. Bobby Bright (D) of Alabama and Rep. Travis Childers (D) of Mississippi, who took office last year, are other possible party defectors, Professor Black says. They have voting records similar to Griffith's, represent similarly conservative districts, and are likely to encounter similar sentiments from voters.

According to MSNBC’s "First Read," a political blog, Democrats are hardly surprised by Griffith's move, given his voting record and given that he had once asked people to not call him a Democrat, but simply a "Blue Dog."

Yet Democrats argue that Griffith’s switch pales in comparison with Sen. Arlen Specter’s defection from the Republican Party, which helped give the Democratic caucus its current 60-vote supermajority.

For tradition-bound Southerners, change may simply be happening too fast in Washington. But it's also possible that Griffith's frustrations with the direction of the Democratic Party are shared beyond Dixie, Black says.

“The Democrats have gone too far, gone way too liberal, changing one-sixth of the whole economy [with proposed healthcare reform],” says Black. “This is really big social change.”

* * *

Good grief, it's not even 2010 and the campaign is on.

Buckle up ... patsy

Comments
(9)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
CDavidS1951
|
January 05, 2010
I hope he never switches. He's lied out of both sides of his mustache so much, he fits right in with his fellow "D's". I want to see him beat because no one can tell what he is.
noonetoyou
|
January 02, 2010
has anyone reviewed the health care reform? How much will this cost everyone? Is it even legal to mandate everyone to buy insurance? If you can't afford insurance you will be forced into a public one! Have any of you been to a public hospital or clinic? Do you have a clue the wait time to get a appointment or the wait time to see a doctor, if you lucky.. most of the time you see a nurse practioner who does the assement and treatment! If things are moving to fast for southerns, then we better start running to catch up with everyone! From my perspective this health care bill is bad news! Health care reform is needed no doubt, but be aware of what it entails!
5960lady
|
December 28, 2009
For the first time in a long time our service men and women got raises across the board ever one got a raise,

ever thing that the american people enjoy the dems. have done the work a passed bills todo it.

unemployment droped this last week in 15 mos,spending is up and the economy is getting better theres still more to do and i know it will be a lot better by this time next year.

Now abouth childers he is doing what he has todo to keep his job in washington,so nothing he does will surprize me or any dem, he vote no the same as the republicans.

The onley reason the republican part got so strong here is because of civil rights and to hate any one that took up the fight for civil rights for ever one not just white men.

Do you know what socialism means,well let me tell you, a theory or system of goverment based on publice owbership and controlof the means of production and distribution of goods. the people of the united states or the public and we do own many things and we move goods.

the health care bill is not done yet and i think it will be a good reform for everone that has insurance and for people that can't get insurance can get it and the ones that can't pay a high prem.can get insurance that is a good thing,

The democrates or for democracy always.

Mr.T
|
December 28, 2009
MIKEOWEN, You should have reminded them that every time that they or their parent's or their grandparent's receive a social security check, or use their medicare card, that they should thank the democrats.

For those that are younger, every time you have gotten a raise when the minimum wage has risen, or have received a unemployment check, thank a democrat. Because the republicans have fought hard against every damned one of these programs!

I wonder what the percentage of Mississippians today that have benefited from one or more of these programs.
Woolhat
|
December 24, 2009
Hey, Mike. Do a little research on that 'thank a Democrat for electricity" bit. There were business driven projects underway to electrify some areas when they were put on hold to defend the TVA's bailiwick.

It is certain that electrification would have occurred, with or without the TVA. In a different form, certainly, but it's hard to say what that form would be like.

To assume that we'd still be suffering from hookworm, shoeless in feces-laced clay, watching a kerosene powered TV except for the sagacity of Democrats is akin to assuming that except for the Republicans, slaves would still be gathering the raw material for Kotex.

There are dynamics of business development that government may delay, but is powerless to abort -- witness Red China's embrace of capitalism.
sandlot1959
|
December 23, 2009
Mike you make sense sometimes but that last line was a load of BS...Comparing this healthcare to indoor plumbing is ridiculous...and I certainly dont give a crap what sex nor what color someone is...you can take your "backwards southern ways" crap and put it where the sun dont shine...I care about what is good for America...I think most of the people that are arguing against any of this crap they're trying to pull...in your posts you seem intelligent but if you see nothing wrong with whats going on in this country over the last year, then I am wrong and you really dont have a clue...this IS socialism and you can support it and then live with it but you'll be one of the first ones to complain about how its cramping your freedoms...if you think so dang lowly of southerners, then why dont you get the crap out? Good day sir...
MIKEOWEN
|
December 23, 2009
I beleive the Christian Scientist reporter nailed the problem, "change is happening to fast for most Southerners". first a female speaker of the house and then a black president is to much for the average Southern male. Then dazed and confused they make easy picking for the Right Wing/Fascist party.

What my Yahoo friends and associates don't remember or are not old enough to know is that most of the what they enjoy now like indoor plumbing and electric lights was made possible by some very FISCAL liberal Mississippi politicians. So the next time they turn a light switch they should thank a DEMOCRAT.
halfprice
|
December 23, 2009
You know, I used to raise Democrat dogs, then their eyes would open so they could see and they became Republicans. I was a democrat til I learned what they were really about. Maybe a couple of them will open their eyes before they become the full Socialist party. I applaud any of these men or women that can admit they were wrong.

sandlot1959
|
December 23, 2009
I called his office and urged them that he change affiliation...if he does, he will win re-election fairly handily but will more than likely lose if he doesn't, even if his voting record is generally conservative...he supported Pelosi for speaker and the only thing that will overshadow that fact is if he changes parties...