Barbour: The lame duck who isn’t
by Bobby Harrison/NEMS Daily Journal
10 months ago | 1582 views | 6 6 comments | 10 10 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Generally, at this point in the political process chief executives begin to lose clout and influence. Their adversaries know they are prohibited from running for another term, and their allies begin to position themselves with a new leader.

It will be six years this week since Barbour, a Yazoo City native, upended incumbent Democrat Ronnie Musgrove to win the Governor’s Mansion, and his time as the state’s CEO is winding down.

But no one utters the words “lame duck” when referring to Haley Barbour.

“I’m confident Governor Barbour will continue to focus on fiscal responsibility within state government as well as successfully recruiting more good-paying jobs to our state to give us a strong rebound to this national economic downturn,” said Republican Lt. Gov. Phil Bryant, who many believe is vying to replace Barbour as governor.

Barbour’s clout was as strong as ever back in June when he and legislators raced to finally pass a budget before the new fiscal year began on July 1.

On a Sunday night early that month, House and Senate negotiators celebrated after finally reaching an agreement on the issue that was stalling negotiations – Medicaid.

But before long, Barbour made it clear he opposed the agreement. The Senate leadership, a group that has been heavily influenced by Barbour, fell in line with the governor, and it was back to the negotiating table.

Unmatched influence

Even with two years left on Barbour’s second term, observers already note his place in Mississippi’s political history.

“I don’t know if there will be another governor able to exert the control over the Senate that Haley has,” said political scientist Marty Wiseman, director of the Stennis Institute of Government at Mississippi State University.

“Regardless of how one feels about his politics, he took the office of governor, considered a weak office constitutionally compared to the Legislature, and demonstrated how by force of personality to make a strong office of governor.”

At one point during the past legislative session, it appeared that Barbour finally would have his first veto overridden.

The House overrode his veto of a bill preventing the taking of private property for use by another private entity, and it looked as though the same would happen in the Senate, where many of his Republican colleagues were the chief sponsors of the proposal.

But Barbour met with and persuaded a group of Democratic senators – many his main political opponents – to sustain his veto

The override failed.

“There’s no doubt that Governor Barbour has been very successful because of his ability to always think ahead, as well as his natural, conversational way to communicate a clear and concise message whether it is one-on-one , to small groups or large audiences,” said Bryant, who for the rare occasion was on the opposite side of Barbour on the property rights legislation.

While Barbour has had considerable legislative success, things have not always been rosy for him. Earlier on, some decisions regarding cuts in Medicaid were controversial and unpopular.

His Katrina legacy

Many believed his strength was bolstered by the generally high marks he received in his response to Hurricane Katrina that slammed south Mississippi in August 2005 – the second year of his term.

“His legacy will certainly be, a large part of it, his performance during Katrina and the aftermath,” Wiseman said. “I think his entire time as governor would have been a lot different if not for what he was able to do there.

“Remember, when Katrina hit he was attempting to get out of the briar patch of trying to cut 65,000 people from Medicaid and schoolteachers were getting mad at him. He performed with a great deal of decisiveness based on that natural disaster. That gave him the benefit of the doubt on a lot of other things. Plus, a great deal of Katrina money helped the state.”

Still, the House, led by Speaker Billy McCoy, D-Rienzi, has at times held the governor in check. For instance, through the years the House has forced the governor to spend more on education than he originally proposed.

“I think his legacy will be how hard he worked to recruit additional business and industry,” said McCoy. “Needless to say, Katrina will be part of his legacy. He receives high marks for that.

“We could all find some cracks in the recovery, but I don’t think you could criticize his effort.”

McCoy has been at odds with Barbour in the past, saying that he was trying to be a king instead of governor. On this particular day, he refused to criticize Barbour, but others weren’t as reserved in their comments.

Because of his influence over the Senate, “He has pretty much undermined the role of the Legislature,” said Rep. Kelvin Buck, D-Holly Springs. “He has been fairly difficult to work with....It has really been difficult finding common ground.”

Playing on the big stage

Many have accused the 62-year-old Barbour of bringing partisan politics to the state, and his immense fundraising ability and his campaigning skills have changed the Mississippi political landscape.

The debate about whether the change is good or bad will linger for years.

But Sen. Terry Brown, R-Columbus, said, “His legacy will be as the best economic development governor we have ever had. That is because of all his contacts in Washington.”

Barbour, a former high-powered Washington lobbyist, former chair of the Republican National Committee and former political director to President Ronald Reagan, is viewed as not only a power in Mississippi, but in national politics.

His name has been in the mix as a possible presidential candidate in 2012. He has been coy on the matter, saying Republicans should focus on winning elections this year and in 2010 before even thinking about the presidential campaign.

“I could see him being the king maker a whole lot more than the king,” said Wiseman, referring to his ability to influence key Republicans on the national level.

During his final two years, it appears that much of Barbour’s focus will be on dealing with historically bad budget problems caused by the national recession.

He still is working on economic development as witnessed by a recent trip to Asia and efforts to land a German manufacturer in the Delta.

“Haley has made state government work,” said Secretary of State Delbert Hosemann. “However, his legacy may well be his leadership through the state’s fiscal crisis, and his abilities to make tough decisions with a long-range view.”

Contact Bobby Harrison at (601) 353-3119 or bobby.harrison@djournal.com.

In Mississippi, Barbour rules the Republican roost

JACKSON – As Gov. Haley Barbour enters his final two years in office, he is still considered in Republican circles either the class favorite or the tough kid who strikes fear in everyone else.

Perhaps he is both.

“It amazes me how not only Republicans, but a goodly number of rural, conservative Democrats want the world to know they are with him,” said Marty Wiseman, political scientist and director of the Mississippi State University Stennis Institute of Government.

No polling has been made public recently gauging the popularity of the 62-year-old Yazoo City native.

But based on his overwhelming re-election in November 2007 – he received nearly 58 percent of the vote – and an abundance of anecdotal evidence, he continues to have wide support among the state’s populace.

And with at least high-profile Mississippi Republicans, the respect and adulation he engenders are almost mystical.

“I think Governor Barbour’s influence on Mississippi politics will be long-lasting and historic because he’s taken on huge challenges and made a difference for our state,” said Republican Lt. Gov. Phil Bryant.

Republican Treasurer Tate Reeves said, “Future leaders will be wise to lean on Governor Barbour.”

Gulf Coast businessman Dave Dennis, who’s indicated he’ll run for governor in 2011, is another Republican who regularly lauds Barbour’s tenure and influence.

Seldom does a Republican official buck the governor, and no GOP candidate in Mississippi wants to get on Barbour’s bad side.

Barbour and Bryant have clashed occasionally on policy issues, but the first-term lieutenant governor, who is eying a run for governor in 2011, is careful to avoid public spats with Barbour, who constitutionally is prevented from seeking a third term.

Many believe that while Barbour will not be on the ballot in 2011, he will be involved in the elections.

That should not be surprising. He has been involved in politics most of his life, going back to 1968 and his leadership role in Richard Nixon’s presidential campaign in Mississippi.

“If Haley can look back and see crafting a Republican-majority Legislature, or at least cutting the Democratic majority by half in the House, having a slight advantage in the Senate and then having all eight statewide office holders as Republican, I think he will see his legacy as a success on the political side,” Wiseman said.

Attempts to get comments from Barbour were unsuccessful.

Wiseman said he believes Barbour would like his final achievement – as far as party politics goes – to be exerting influence on the legislative redistricting in 2011 to ensure more Republicans are elected to the House and Senate.

Technically, the governor has no say in the process, which is controlled solely by the Legislature. But Barbour has demonstrated unprecedented success during his tenure in being able to exert influence over lawmakers – especially in the Senate – and Wiseman expects the redistricting process to be no different.

“I can’t fathom him sitting all that out,” Wiseman said.

And it would be hard to imagine Barbour sitting out the 2011 elections, though most believe he will not get involved publicly in the Republican primary to support one candidate over another.

Many, though, believe that behind the scenes Barbour supported former state Sen. Charlie Ross of Brandon, who was defeated by Bryant in the 2007 Republican primary for lieutenant governor. If that is the case, it provides a glimpse of the strength of Bryant, in his on right, in Republican Party circles.

Regardless, Barbour was instrumental in getting Ross and Bryant together after a contentious primary for a news conference to display Republican unity.

Don’t be surprised if he plays a similar role in 2011 even as he leaves office.

Contact Bobby Harrison at (601) 353-3119 or bobby.harrison@djournal.com.
comments (6)
« sandlot1959 wrote on Monday, Nov 02 at 12:27 AM »
Hi BFD...you out here wreaking havoc again? LOL...your name is similar to a brand of underwear...maybe you should change it to 'FruitOfTheLooney'....LOL....
report abuse
« BFD wrote on Sunday, Nov 01 at 07:18 PM »
he as a girl name, hehehe. Haley is a girl name. He's like a boy named Sue
report abuse
« sandlot1959 wrote on Sunday, Nov 01 at 03:31 PM »
Well Mr T, I just dont know where the money to help them would come from...and I'm sure he's mindful of helping furniture mfg while making cuts in education and other programs and what the outcry would be to that...catch 22 I guess...I just like having a governor that upon recieving tax numbers, immediately goes into "cut mode" to get us back inline...definitely not something that is happening very much in this country--certainly not in congress...
report abuse
« Mr.T wrote on Sunday, Nov 01 at 01:51 PM »
Haley is very much pro business. Which makes me wonder why he has refused to help the furniture industry, when they have asked for it. The last report that I read, is that he even refuses to meet with the leader's of that industry. He cannot be happy with all the downsizing that have cost jobs in our area.
report abuse
« sandlot1959 wrote on Sunday, Nov 01 at 11:09 AM »
woolhat....I have to say that I have respect for YOU for your comments seeing as you arent a Republican...I was lukewarm on Haley when he first ran even though I knew his pedigree. Interestingly, the only time he's really had popularity problems as governor is when he is trying to force the legislature to live within its own budget...To be honest, I've already ordered and received my "HALEY BARBOUR IN 1012" bumper stickers...LOL..I've certainly changed my mind about him...Like you said, I believe he's got a good bit of what made Reagan successful and I believe he can translate it to the national level as President....I'd be very happy to just have him be the "King Maker" too though...take care...:)
report abuse
« Woolhat wrote on Sunday, Nov 01 at 08:13 AM »
I'm not a Republican, but I confess to admiring The Guv's political skills. In politics, nothing so endears an official to the electorate as the image of competence -- Reagan had it, Carter didn't, Barbour has it, Musgrove didn't, etc.

The Governor has an identifiable set of principles, and acts consistently with it. He works for the interest of his constituency, and doesn't try to placate his enemies by assuming their form (GWB's downfall; never works -- alienates your supporters and fails to impress the enemies).

Just as a family doesn't need a "buddy" sitting at the head of the table, but a Father, so the State doesn't need someone to feel our pain, but a Leader. Love him or hate him, you gotta admit, The Governor fills the bill.
report abuse