Itawamba lesbian student hits national stage in prom flap
by Chris Kieffer/NEMS Daily Journal
5 months ago | 4972 views | 175 175 comments | 25 25 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Constance McMillen
Constance McMillen
slideshow
FULTON – Constance McMillen has done a lot of praying lately.

She’s also done a lot of talking as she finds herself in the center of a growing nationwide controversy sparked by her fight to attend her high school prom with her girlfriend.

Media outlets across the nation interviewed the 18-year-old senior at Itawamba Agricultural High School one day after the Itawamba County School District announced it would cancel its April 2 prom. The announcement came a week and a day after the ACLU sent a letter on McMillen’s behalf to the district, demanding it change its prohibition on same-sex dates at the prom.

McMillen said her girlfriend has not publicly revealed her identity because the girl’s parents disapprove of the relationship.

A couple of efforts began on Thursday to try to restore that dance. The ACLU filed a federal lawsuit in Oxford asking the court to reinstate the prom for all students. Meanwhile, several parents of IAHS juniors and seniors met Thursday night to discuss holding their own prom for students at the school.

Although McMillen said she has faced vitriol and anger from students who blame her for canceling the prom, she cites the support of family, friends and the ACLU for helping her through a trying time. She also credits her faith.

“God has helped me, and I’ve been praying a lot,” McMillen said. “Regardless of what you believe, I’m a Christian. Sexual orientation doesn’t make a religion.”

McMillen returned to school on Thursday, but she found “so much tension and hostility.” Students silently stared as she walked through the hallway, she said, and one student screamed, “Thanks for ruining my senior year.” She left around 10 a.m.

“It was too much for me today,” McMillen said.

The 668-student high school sent all of its students a memo on Feb. 5 stating the rules for the prom, including one requirment that dates “must be of the opposite sex.” Even before the memo was sent, McMillen, who missed the prom last year, asked school officials if she would be allowed to attend. They told her that she couldn’t come with her girlfriend and if other students saw them at the dance together and complained, she could be asked to leave.

Looking for an outlet, she contacted the Mississippi Safe Schools Coalition, which was formed in the fall of 2008 to deal with discrimination faced by lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender students in Mississippi public schools and colleges. The coalition put her in touch with the ACLU of Mississippi, which sent a letter to the district on March 2 demanding that it change its policy by Wednesday or possibly face legal action.

“I didn’t think the school would carry it that far,” McMillen said. “I couldn’t believe they would rather punish everybody than do the right thing.

“What I got from it is that if they had to let gay people go, they would rather cancel the prom. It is sad they feel that way about it... I’m upset but I’m not angry. You can’t be mad because some people have different beliefs.”

The Daily Journal spoke to Superintendent Teresa McNeece at her office but she said she had no comment on the district’s decision. A message left with school board chairman Eddie Hood was not returned.

Google Trends ranked McMillen “on fire” on a day when she was featured by outlets like CNN, USA Today, MSNBC and Headline News. This morning, she will be in New York for on interview on the CBS Early Show. An ACLU Facebook page created about her fight on Thursday had 40,000 fans by 11:30 p.m. A Daily Journal story about McMillen on NEMS360.com had the highest number of views and comments ever for a single story on the site.

McMillen’s father, Michael McMillen, said he stands by his daughter.

“Whatever makes her happy, I’m OK with,” Michael McMillen said. “We differ on opinion about certain things, but all in all, if this is what she wants, I’m completely supportive. In no way would I discriminate or hold things against somebody for choosing that life.”

He said that he and his daughter have talked about the scope of a fight that has grown much larger than his daughter’s original stance.

“She understands it is not about the person, it is about the movement and the right to choose who she wants to be,” he said.

The ACLU filed Thursday’s lawsuit with the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Mississippi. It claims the First Amendment gives students the right to bring same-sex dates to school dances.

ACLU Legal Director Kristy Bennett did not return a message seeking comment about the suit. But in a release, she said that public schools “can’t censor someone’s free expression just because some other person might not like it.”

“Itawamba school officials are trying to turn Constance into the villain who caused the prom to be canceled, but that just isn’t what happened,” Bennett said in the statement. “She’s fighting for everyone to be able to enjoy the prom.”

Contact Chris Kieffer at (662) 678-1590 or chris.kieffer@djournal.com.

Click here for yesterday's story which had more than 12,000 views and more than 400 comments.
comments (175)
« tupelofamily wrote on Monday, Mar 15 at 09:07 AM »
What Jesus did teach: Love them(all sinners) to Christ. Yes, for a fact, gay men and women, can hear the Word and turn away from their sinful act. Just as murderers, adulters, prostitutes,pedofiles, and all of the other sinful things we as people get caught up in.

The Bible does speak of "men laying with men and women lay with women; refers to this as an abomination."

I am a Christian, and I am not perfect. I challenge you to be open minded to the Bible. Don't change the message it has to suit your needs. I know there are "preachers" who are sugar coating God's Word. Read His Words for what they are; don't add and don't take away.

I will say this one last time, I do not HATE anyone, not even you VICTORIOUSUNION...I don't have any mental disorders, paranoia, or whatever all that other stuff was you called me. I am tolerant of others and their choices, after all God does give us the freedom to make bad choices too. He forgives me.
report abuse
« VictoriousUnion wrote on Sunday, Mar 14 at 06:47 PM »
anonymous: Easy answer. Jesus made absolutely no mention or reference to same-sex attraction.
report abuse
« anonymous wrote on Sunday, Mar 14 at 03:31 PM »
I read a lot of "bible thumping" going on here. Trouble is, the loudest proponents of biblical morality know the littlest about the rules they foam about. So does anyone here that is "Christian" know what Jesus taught about homosexuality? His attitude toward it? How about what Jesus would do if he had the ability to decide on this prom? What would he do?
report abuse
« VictoriousUnion wrote on Sunday, Mar 14 at 12:52 PM »
tupelofamily: Nothing of what you say even resembles "absolute truth". Thankfully, I'm not the one exploiting God just to feel better about my hatred. I leave that to you Fundies.

tupelo, you are not persecuted. Paranoid Personality Disorder has a symptom --- systematized delusions of persecution. I'm glad to see you may now know the name for your mental illness. Persecuted? Hmm... I don't see any school boards canceling prom because a Fundamentalist Christian might attend.

Finally, it is quite obvious you know very little ABOUT Scripture. You might be able to quote, but you will never grasp its historical, theological, or practical context. As I have said so many times, Fundamentalist Christianity is predicated upon the ignorance of its followers. You merely confirm that notion.
report abuse
« tupelofamily wrote on Sunday, Mar 14 at 09:46 AM »
I guess you know I'm speaking directly to you. We "humble" ourselves because of OUR personal sins. We pray for the world's sins. What would you like us to do; roll over and play dead? Not going to happen. Christians are persecuted all over the world, not just here.

The school board at IAHS has a right to say what they will do or won't do. I have no idea who their board members are but I'm sure they didn't make their decision on the spur of a moment.



You have made your sarcastic comments enough.

"P.S. I've never mocked the Lord. I mock those who exploit His Name for their own hatred and ignorance. I know better than to blame Him for the absolute idiots who committed such atrocities in His Name." These are your words exactly. Looks to me like absolute truth REALLY bothers you. Don't take it from me, open your Bible and read it again.

report abuse
« VictoriousUnion wrote on Saturday, Mar 13 at 11:20 PM »
tupelofamily: "Humble" yourselves??? LOL. If you humbled yourself, a same-sex couple attending their high school prom would be of no issue to you. Canceling a high school prom doesn't turn one person "away" from sin. Quit deluding yourself.

See, if you think getting the high school prom canceled somehow edifies or strengthens Christ, you're too lost to be helped.

P.S. I've never mocked the Lord. I mock those who exploit His Name for their own hatred and ignorance. I know better than to blame Him for the absolute idiots who committed such atrocities in His Name.
report abuse
« tupelofamily wrote on Saturday, Mar 13 at 10:36 PM »
VICT-UN... you crack me up...I don't recall "treating" anyone bad. You my friend have lashed out at everyone who has a different opinion than you. You think we're a joke, or entertaining. I'm happy you've been amused.

I feel really bad for you. You have sarcasticly "mocked" the Lord. I hope you're done. I have respect for Him.

For everyone else who have "called out" the Christians or "church goers" as you say, We are not perfect and we know that. We humble ourselves and admitt we are sinners that's why you find us worshipping the Lord and reading the Bible. Yes we all sin daily. But what seperates us from the world is we admitt we are sinners; we need Him. We TRY to turn away from sin; not indulge in it.

report abuse
« VictoriousUnion wrote on Saturday, Mar 13 at 05:04 PM »
tupelofamily: You don't like being treated in the same manner you treat others? Ah... maybe you'll learn to THINK before you speak.
report abuse
« VictoriousUnion wrote on Saturday, Mar 13 at 05:03 PM »
suaveguy: There's nothing else that needs to be said to you.
report abuse
« tupelofamily wrote on Saturday, Mar 13 at 02:53 PM »
VICT-UN....Looks like you quote other people the same way you quote the Bible...you only use the parts you want...

You bore me now...
report abuse
« suaveguy83 wrote on Saturday, Mar 13 at 01:08 PM »
VictoriousUnion sounds like a broken record:

"pray for the gay away"

"pray for the gay away"

...LOLOL what a sore loser
report abuse
« VictoriousUnion wrote on Saturday, Mar 13 at 12:39 PM »
tupelofamily asks, "why are you still posting on our local newspaper site?"

Easy... you all are an excellent source of entertainment.
report abuse
« VictoriousUnion wrote on Saturday, Mar 13 at 12:38 PM »
ConcernedAmerican thinks Leviticus is part of the Gospel now. Wow! Yet another example of how fundamentalist Christianity is predicated upon the ignorance of its followers.
report abuse
« VictoriousUnion wrote on Saturday, Mar 13 at 12:36 PM »
iheartlife compares same-sex attraction with rape and murder. Wow. I'm sure Jesus is VERY proud of that one.
report abuse
« VictoriousUnion wrote on Saturday, Mar 13 at 12:34 PM »
suaveguy: Keep on trying to "pray the gay away", and you fail miserably. You will also die a miserable person. Seek legitimate professional help.
report abuse
« scar-strangled-banter wrote on Saturday, Mar 13 at 08:59 AM »
VICTORIOUS UNION, PLEEZE WRITE A BOOK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
report abuse
« straightsense wrote on Saturday, Mar 13 at 12:40 AM »
I read this lawsuit today. It appears the girl and the ACLU think the public school is required to give her a venue to declare her homosexuality. I think I read someones comment this appeared to be a setup/planned and orchestrated deal. From what has been seen thus far, that appears to be true. What is evident, she and her ACLU Attorneys have not pursued the proper appeals process for her complaint within the state of Mississippi.

I'll say this. The judges assigned to the case (Judge Glenn Davidson & Magistrate Jerry Davis) have proven themselves to be homosexual friendly in the past, so its no telling what will happen.

I was not impressed with the law the ACLU presented in support of their complaint. It was not fully paraphrased nor was some of it from a final appellant order. If the school pursues it, their seems to be more law supporting their position of not having a prom within their rights. Thus, no person was discriminated against more than another, a reasonable remedy to the complaint.

Hang on for the ride folks. This one may well become a cat fight. It is apparent discovery will uncover criminal violations commited by the ACLU, the girl and possibly the girls parents. Now you don't want school to enable, encourage or allow criminal activity do you ?
report abuse
« ktt6256 wrote on Saturday, Mar 13 at 12:10 AM »
You know this is just not right! Whatever happen to America being the land of the free? For anyone to tell a human being to another human being that they cannot wear what they wanna wear or they cant bring whomever they wanna bring to the prom is just wrong!! It does not matter what your religion beliefs are, or how you were raised, these are just stupid excuses. And for the school to say that it would be a distraction for the students if they went to the prom seriously we are in 2010, not 1920!!! I hope this school gets sued and the person or people that made this decision to cancel the prom seriously grow up and get a life!! I hope they lose their jobs because never fly so high you think you will never land!! They will get theirs eventually!
report abuse
« shoppin wrote on Friday, Mar 12 at 11:13 PM »
@ ultracreep - I know the jobs discussion doesn't have anything to do with being gay, but you were the one that went there, I was just following up on your comment. You implied that Mississippian's were uneducated and that we should be grateful that you'd "lower" yourself to come here and do a job that no one around here was willing or capable of doing. And most lawyers, teachers, nurses & doctors that I personally know are native Mississippians, so again, your comment doesn't hold much water. Sweet dreams!
report abuse
« Tupelo_WTF wrote on Friday, Mar 12 at 10:34 PM »
well said 'justamom003" !!! I have noticed some mean spirited "christians" on here today, there seems to be a lot of hate from these people who worship a loving God.
report abuse